Home   Contact Phil 


 


Phil Mellows is a freelance
 journalist living in Brighton 
 


Hear about the latest on this site at Twitter ...
Phil on
Posterous ...    Phil's blog on the CPL Training website ...


         
        The politics of drinking

           
May 23, 2013


 

 

Stats are the real cause of concern
The misuse of alcohol statistics

Aiming to Serve and Protect
Alcohol policy according to shopkeepers on the frontline

Winning Over the Doubters
Interview with serial pub entrepreneur David Bruce

Your good health?
Drink and the politics of public health

The Benefits of Preloading
Having a drink before you go out may not be so awful

Alcohol and the State
Governments have been wrestling with drinking issues for centuries

The Musical Moderniser
Interview with Fran Nevrkla, chairman of PPL

Bar room brawl
Government alcohol policy and the drinks industry

A man of culture
Interview with Gavin George, who runs 43 pubs in Brighton

All in the detail
Interview with telly troubleshooter and pub entrepreneur Martin Webb

The romance of brewing
Interview with Harvey's Miles Jenner, Brewer of the Year


Having his Tuppen'orth
Interview with Britain's biggest pub owner

Part of the solution?
Interview with Drinkaware chief Chris Sorek

The Price of Cask Beer
Should pubs be charging more?

Demonising Drink
Inside the health lobby

The Beer Orders 20 years on
The story of the law that changed the pub industry

Cask has lift-off
Why cask beer is back in growth

Alcoholism in the pub trade
The issue that dare not speak its name

Standing out from the crowd
What successful pubs do that others don't

Tipping points
What you need to know about the new rules

A Night on West Street
Policing the night-time economy 
in Brighton

Read all about it
Recycling today's news... into the day after tomorrow's news

The People's Pubs
When nationalisation was the answer

On the Road to Prohibition?
Temperance is back on the agenda

Meet Mick the Tick
The king of the beer tickers

From Rags to Riches
A 21st Century Steptoe & Son

Scot Topics
Retailers in Scotland are under pressure...

A Constant State 
of Flux 

The 1989 Beer Orders

A Lesson from the Past
How the trade united in 1908

From the slums to the lap
of luxury

Gin has come a long way

Marketers move in on 
Mardi Gras

Southern Comfort: the spirit of 
New Orleans


Big pharma and alcohol research

One thing the public health lobby has going for it, when it comes to alcohol, is that there’s relatively little in the way of influence from private capital - companies which might profit from efforts to reduce overall consumption.

There are, of course, private clinics and drugs that aim to assist in alcohol treatment, but they tend to distance themselves from population-wide strategies which, I suppose, might conceivably do them out of business.

In the last few days, though, that has changed. You might have noticed some research among MPs about their own drinking habits hitting the headlines. In fact, the results contradicted the headlines in that most MPs didn’t think there was a problem. But no matter.

The research was conducted by Alcohol Concern - and funded by a pharmaceutical company called Lundbeck. It was all done according to a code of practice, but it’s surely no coincidence, as Christopher Snowden spotted, that Lundbeck has just launched a new drug that claims to help people reduce their drinking.

Within minutes of discovering this I got a tweet inviting me to publicise an “alcohol societal survey” being carried out by The Wellbeing Alliance. And guess who’s sponsoring it? Lundbeck again. Clearly there is a strategy going on, probably linked to the new drug, Selincro.

Selincro is an ‘opiode system modulator’ which works in a different way to existing alcohol treatment drugs by directly targeting the system in the brain that regulates the urge to drink, supposedly broken in dependent drinkers.

I’m not convinced you can separate this from social and emotional factors but, anyway, the other distinctive thing about Selincro, says Lundbeck, is that its aim is consumption reduction rather than abstention. Trials saw individuals cut their drinking by an average 60%.

It’s nice to see this as an option, but it suggests that Selincro might have a wider application than other alcohol treatment drugs. Promoting the idea that more of us have a drink problem that we like to think could well benefit Lundbeck.

And the Wellbeing Alliance survey seems to designed to do just that. It’s not a targeted survey. Anyone can fill it in. The questions are around drinking patterns and the impact of drinking. They include: “Are you always able to stop drinking when you want to?” (Though not: “Would you like to take something to help you do that?”)

No doubt the results will produce some headlines, but it’s unlikely they’ll advance very far our understanding of alcohol dependence.

Does it matter that it’s sponsored by a drugs company? If the drug manufactured was alcohol any research, however rigorous, would be deemed fatally tainted.

As state funding is pulled, we can expect more privately sponsored research like this. I don’t want to say that anything should be automatically dismissed. But we need to be aware of commercial interests and sort out our attitude to them.



Previously:

Big pharma and alcohol research

Thatcher’s alcohol legacy
Part 2: The New Public Health 

The drinks industry and alcohol policy: why all the fuss?

Thatcher’s alcohol legacy
Part 1: The Beer Orders  

Having your pint and drinking it too? The ‘problem’ of falling alcohol consumption

Getting drunk with Kettil Bruun


Diary Archive 


Latest reviews: 

No Man's Land by Harold Pinter

Bernard Shaw Invites You!

Side Effects

Zero Dark Thirty - Django Unchained

The Hunt

The Killing III


Reviews


 

 

 









 

Writing... Journalism... Research... Awards Judging... Pub Business Advice... Pub Crawls
Contact Phil